Santino's Pizza
If you’re craving mouthwatering, authentic pizza in a cozy and welcoming environment, Santino’s Pizza located at 2 Main St, Oakfield, NY 14125 is the place to be. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Santino’s offers an unforgettable dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more. With a perfect blend of quality ingredients, traditional cooking techniques, and excellent service, this family-owned pizzeria has become a beloved spot for pizza lovers of all ages.
Why Santino’s Pizza Stands Out
What makes Santino’s Pizza unique isn’t just the delicious pizza—it’s the entire experience. As you walk into the restaurant, you’re greeted with a warm, friendly atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. The team at Santino’s believes in offering more than just a meal; they create a welcoming space for families, friends, and anyone looking for a great meal.
The menu at Santino’s is extensive, catering to all tastes and preferences. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic cheese pizza, a loaded meat lover’s pizza, or a veggie-packed option, you’ll find something to satisfy your cravings. The pizzas are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients—nothing frozen here. From the rich, savory tomato sauce to the perfectly melted mozzarella cheese, every bite is a testament to Santino’s dedication to great pizza.
A Slice of Tradition
Santino’s Pizza has a rich history of crafting pizzas the traditional way. Each pizza is prepared using a secret family recipe passed down through generations. The dough is made fresh daily, ensuring a crispy yet soft crust that complements every topping. The sauce, bursting with flavor, is carefully seasoned to bring out the best in every pizza. Plus, the toppings are always fresh and locally sourced, ensuring the highest quality with every slice.
Beyond the pizza, Santino’s menu features a range of Italian favorites, from savory pasta dishes to delicious calzones and subs. For those looking for a quick bite, there are also plenty of appetizers, including garlic knots, breadsticks, and crispy wings that are perfect for sharing.
Expertly Crafted with Passion
The team behind Santino’s Pizza brings years of experience and expertise to the kitchen. Each member of the team is committed to delivering the best pizza experience possible. Whether it's the chef’s keen eye for flavor combinations or the friendly staff providing excellent service, Santino’s ensures every visit is a memorable one.
One of the standout features of Santino’s is its emphasis on quality. They source only the freshest ingredients and maintain a commitment to making each pizza from scratch. This dedication to quality is reflected not only in the flavor of the food but also in the high standards of service.
Local Favorite and Trusted Name
In a town like Oakfield, where community is key, Santino’s Pizza has earned a reputation as a trusted name. The pizzeria has become a staple of the local dining scene, known for its consistent quality and exceptional customer service. Many regulars attest to the warm and welcoming atmosphere, as well as the personalized touch that makes every visit special. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a casual meal, Santino’s provides an experience that feels like home.
Why You Should Visit Santino’s Pizza
So, why should you make Santino’s Pizza your next dining destination? Here are a few compelling reasons:
- Authentic, hand-crafted pizza: Enjoy pizza made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and traditional methods that stand out from the competition.
- A welcoming environment: With friendly staff and a cozy ambiance, Santino’s Pizza offers a dining experience that feels like part of the Oakfield community.
- Variety of options: From pizza to pasta, calzones, and subs, there’s something for everyone on the menu.
- Commitment to quality: Every pizza is made with care and attention to detail, ensuring a top-notch meal with every visit.
- Local favorite: Join the many satisfied customers who make Santino’s their go-to pizza spot in Oakfield.
Whether you're a pizza connoisseur or simply someone who enjoys a great meal, Santino’s Pizza is a place you’ll want to visit. It’s more than just a pizzeria—it’s a community gathering spot where great food and friendly service come together to create the ultimate dining experience.
Reviews
It's really hard to justify a 5-star rating, but I definitely feel this place is at least a 4.25 so I figure it will weigh itself out. The crust is crispy yet gives a little, and the undercarriage is solid with little flop. They could put a little more sauce on it, but at that point I'm just nitpicking. This is a friendly little spot in small town western NY that is worth a visit.
This place is less than 5 minutes from our house so we have ordered pizza and wings a couple times since we moved in, but our most recent visit was the other night when we needed take out after a week of working at home again. I'm glad to report that we pass by here often and they seem to be pretty busy during this quarantine and we are happy to keep supporting them. Santino's is your traditional pizzeria with basic options, pizza, wings, subs, fish fry, and a variety of apps like pizza logs, mozz sticks, etc. We have only ordered pizza and wings. They don't have many specials, but they have a small pizza and single wings, and a large pizza and double wings. On each occasion we have gotten one of these specials. The small is really plenty for just me and my husband, but sometimes it is nice to have leftovers. On this occasion we got the large special with pepperoni, mushrooms and banana peppers. Overall the pizza is good, but a bit inconsistent particularly with the crust. Sometimes the crust is super doughy which I really love, but sometimes it is hard and a bit overcooked which is how it was on this past visit. The sauce and cheese part has always been good, however in the future I think I'll stick to just one topping as I don't feel like they are ever very generous in that area. My husband doesn't like that they cut a circle pizza into square pieces. It doesn't bother me at all, and we always forget to ask and see if they will cut it normally, so not sure if they would. They also don't feel like pineapple belongs on pizza, so that was a bit sad, but luckily I enjoy lots of different toppings. The have been really solid on each of our visits. The wings are large, meaty and saucy. I also like that a single order of wings consists of 12. We like the BBQ wings, but also enjoy the traditional medium. We usually stick to these 2 options because they are always good. Overall Santino's is a great place for pizza and wings. There is a small area inside to sit (of course not during this time of quarantine). There are also picnic tables set up in the warmer weather, and an attached ice cream shop with an outdoor window. It's a great place to hang out when the weather is nice!
Pizza is bad for my taste. I'm from buffalo and just moved to Oakfield And it does not compare..subs and wings from there are excellent tho, great service.
What an absolute gem. Hot Italian subs - western ny speciality. The pizza is perfect, great crust, an abundance of fresh, real cheese; and the sauce is excellent. Lunch Special of 2 slices and a drink.
Delish! Great service. Food was great. Best pizza we've had in a long time. Stop in and try it! Food was ready quickly too.